The dazzling dozen: 12 mobiles tested

31 October 2003 11:30 AM

Tags: z600, 3g, 3100, kyocera, samsung, review, nokia, phone

 The dazzling dozen

 Mobile phone reviews:

 Kyocera 3245
 Motorola A920
 Nokia 3100
 Nokia 7250
 Nokia 8910i
 Nokia N-Gage
 Samsung SGH-C100
 Samsung SGH-V200
 Sharp GX20
 Siemens MC60
 Sony Ericsson T610
 Sony Ericsson Z600

The dazzling dozen: 12 mobiles tested We take a look at 12 of the latest and greatest mobiles, from high-tech 3G wonders to cheap and cheerful budget phones in our Australian review.

There are segments in the the mobile market that address every single user, be they high-tech executives or chirpy teenagers; there's a model out there for you. We haven't quite got to the stage where there's a Nokia James or a Motorola Wendy, but it can't be far off. The various mobiles we've reviewed here cover uses from serious psuedo-PDA devices all the way to multimedia gaming phones that seem to view the whole calling thing as a mere sideline.

One thing that every phone shares in common, however, is a screen, and it's a factor that many users don't give enough consideration when purchasing a mobile phone. Here at ZDNet Australia we look at an awful lot of mobile phones, and in only a brief period of time our tolerance for what makes a good screen has changed exceptionally rapidly. For example, when the NEC e606 first launched, one of the things we raved about was the screen. Compared to some of the screen available now, the e606 barely rates as average.

So what do we want from a good mobile screen? Obviously a lot of that depends on your usage pattern, but there are some basic rules that apply to every colour mobile screen. For a start, it's got to be visible, and we're not just talking about when you've got your nose pressed right up to it. While you might not want fellow commuters reading what you're perusing, it's no good having a screen that you can't see in bright sunlight.

Then there's the colour question. While a basic screen should be acceptable if you only make calls and send the odd SMS, if you're a heavy MMS or 3G fanatic, it's no good having a screen that blurs or distorts at the first bit of motion. The same is true if you're into mobile gaming.

A mobile screen has to be reasonably robust. Nokia's woes in this area are rather well known, but they're hardly the only mobile provider to have had problems with specific models. Most mobiles, at some point in their life, will suffer some kind of drop damage, and while we don't fancy carrying around the mobile equivalent of a tank, it's annoying to suffer through a screen that stops working just because you dropped a feather on it.

Finally there's the power question. There are plenty of things that suck up battery power on a mobile, and screens can be a main culprit in working out why your brand new phone powerhouse only actually runs for three minutes before conking out. This is something that's in a particular flux at the moment, as while batteries and screen technologies have improved, the introuduction of 2.5/3G phone services has seen the power needs of mobile users accelerate rapidly.


Kyocera 3245Kyocera 3245

The Kyocera 3245 brings another option to the table for CDMA users.

 

 


Motorola A920Motorola A920

The Motorola A920 is a chunky mobile phone with PDA capabilities.

 

 


Nokia 3100Nokia 3100

It's sure to be a hit with teenagers, it glows-in-the-dark and its backlights flash in time with the ringtones.

 


Nokia 7250Nokia 7250

The 7250 marries a solid feature set and excellent battery life.

 

 


Nokia 8910i Nokia 8910i

Nokia's tagline for the 8910i is that it's in a class of its own. That's pretty much true of the price tag, but little else.

 


Nokia N-GageNokia N-Gage

While the N-Gage boasts technology that puts other mobile gaming platforms to shame, design miscues make it a less than stellar choice
for gamers or mobile phone users.



Samsung SGH-C100Samsung SGH-C100

The SGH-C100 has an excellent screen and an acceptable feature set, but it could definitely use a meatier battery.

 


Samsung SGH-V200Samsung SGH-V200

The Samsung SGH-V200 has the stylish appearance typical of Samsung mobiles, with a great screen that the handset maker intends to put in all its phones.



Sharp GX20Sharp GX20

The Sharp GX20 operates on the Vodafone Live service, and replaces the Sharp GX10. The clamshell mobile has the same sleek look as the GX10, and is essentially only slightly improved on it.

 


Siemens MC60Siemens MC60

This is Siemens first handset with an integrated camera and a colour screen. It also sports a funky design and unique, circular keypad. Will it just be a fad or have Siemens come up with a gem?

 


Sony Ericsson T610Sony Ericsson T610

Sony Ericsson's designers have come up with a smooth and sophisticated mobile phone.



 


Sony Ericsson Z600Sony Ericsson Z600

Sony Ericsson's Z600 is a camera phone with a great design and Bluetooth for connectivity. It has all the functionality of the T610 plus it features a larger screen.




Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments


Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay MyPerfect.com.au has potential
    Victorian Web start-up My Perfect has a strong story and rationale for why it will succeed. But it has to overcome some challenges and design flaws first.
  • Array Storage infrastructure on the tender track
    For a large-scale storage project, it's not uncommon to go out to tender for the best deal — but when was the last time you had to put together a tender for a document management room?
  • Array Apple has killed the video store; will ISPs be next?
    The Olympics are nearly over, and the Australian team deserves kudos for an excellent performance all around. Yet even as the Olympic sun sets on the Bird's Nest for the last time this weekend, millions of spectators around the world will be scanning their dials in the hope of finding something else to fill their viewing hours.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured